Updated October 2026 · 42 verified insurance agencies · CAN-SPAM-aware

Wauwatosa Insurance Agencies Contact List — 42 businesses, 7 with email

This contact list covers 42 insurance agencies in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin, delivered as Excel and CSV files the moment you pay $9 USD. Of the 42 businesses, 7 have an email address, 41 a phone number, 33 a website, 42 a street address and 42 a Google rating — a blank cell means the business does not publish that field. Use it for cold email, calling or direct mail to insurance agencies in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin; one purchase includes free updates.

Total Insurance Agencies
42
Across Wauwatosa
With Email
7
17% of listings · 14% corporate domain
Avg Rating
3.38/5
1,027 total reviews
Top Rated
23
Rated 4.5 or higher

The Wauwatosa, Wisconsin insurance agencies list has 42 businesses, 7 of them with a business email. Each record has the business name, phone, address, website and Google rating. One-time $9 USD — download Excel and CSV right after checkout, no subscription.

/ 01 — Sample previewSee what's in the file

Five rows from the full 42-row dataset, sorted by rating & review count. The full file has one row per business with 13 columns: business name, email, email type (business or personal), phone, street address (with postal code), city, state/province, country, Google rating, review count, website, email quality and audit date. The CSV adds email_2, email_3… where a business has more than one address. Service-area businesses (mobile mechanics, handymen, cleaners) deliberately don’t list an address on Google, so that column is blank for about 2% of rows.

insurance-agencies-wauwatosa-wi-usa.xlsx / .csv · 42 rows · 13 columnsPREVIEW
NameRatingReviewsEmail
Dan Schani Insurance Agency★ 5.053—
Magnolia Insurance Group★ 5.010aremigio@fireflyagency.com
Allegiance Insurance Services Inc.★ 5.07—
Lori Nondahl Agency, LLC★ 5.06—
Malone Randall★ 5.02—
+ 37 more rows in the full downloadExcel · CSV

/ 02 — Market insightWauwatosa's insurance agencies market in numbers

“

The Wauwatosa insurance market shows a strong local presence, with 4 out of 6 agencies rated 4.5 or higher. Agencies like Dan Schani Insurance Agency stand out with a 5.0 rating across 52 reviews. Notably, all 6 contacts use webmail addresses, indicating direct access to decision-makers.

42
Active insurance agencies
2%
Corporate domain emails
24
Avg Google reviews

/ 03 — Built forWho buys this list

A

Agency Management Systems

Reach independent insurance agencies in Wauwatosa. Our list includes contact details for all 6 agencies, ideal for platforms like Applied Epic or EZLynx seeking new clients.

B

Carrier Appointment Programs

Connect with local agencies to expand your network. Wauwatosa has agencies with strong reputations, such as Steinfeld Ins. Agency, LLC dba Cream City Insurance with 176 reviews, suitable for direct appointment programs.

C

Marketing & Lead Generation

Target agencies actively seeking growth. The average Google rating of 4.63 across 294 reviews shows engaged businesses ready for marketing services and review platforms.

/ 04 — QuestionsFrequently asked

How many insurance agencies are on the Wauwatosa, WI list?+

Our current verified list includes 6 insurance agencies located in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin. This count reflects actively operating businesses with confirmed contact details.

What contact information is included for each agency?+

Each entry provides essential contact details, including business name, address, phone number, and a verified email address. This ensures you have the necessary information for direct outreach.

Are the email addresses corporate or webmail?+

For Wauwatosa, all 6 email addresses provided are webmail addresses (e.g., Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo). This means you are typically reaching a direct principal or key decision-maker.

How accurate is the data for Wauwatosa insurance agencies?+

PublicLeads prioritizes data verification. Data is refreshed quarterly.

Can I filter the list by agency rating or review count?+

While the full list is provided as a single download, our market insights highlight key metrics. For Wauwatosa, 4 agencies have a rating of 4.5 or higher, indicating strong local standing.

What is the average Google rating for these agencies?+

The 6 insurance agencies in Wauwatosa have an average Google rating of 4.63 out of 5 stars, based on a total of 294 reviews. This indicates a high standard of service within the local market.

Data sourcing, update frequency, bundle pricing & refunds →

/ 05 — Browse moreOther insurance agencies lists in United States

/ DirectoryBrowse Insurance Agencies in Wauwatosa

Find a verified insurance agency near you. Get directions or visit their website directly — sorted by Google rating.

Dan Schani Insurance Agency

★ 5.0 · 53 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Magnolia Insurance Group

★ 5.0 · 10 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Allegiance Insurance Services Inc.

★ 5.0 · 7 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Lori Nondahl Agency, LLC

★ 5.0 · 6 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Bokern Insurance Services

★ 5.0 · 2 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Malone Randall

★ 5.0 · 2 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Donohoo & Sons Insurance Agency

★ 5.0 · 1 review
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Prudential Life Insurance & Financial Services:Rinav Patel

★ 5.0 · 1 review
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Sentry Insurance

★ 5.0 · 1 review
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Steinfeld Ins. Agency, LLC dba Cream City Insurance

★ 4.9 · 178 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Spring Burgess-Ashley - State Farm Insurance Agent

★ 4.9 · 96 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Jared Johnson - State Farm Insurance Agent

★ 4.9 · 54 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Devin Schuckert American Family Insurance

★ 4.9 · 31 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Ron Grumley: Allstate Insurance

★ 4.8 · 112 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Robert Mallow American Family Insurance

★ 4.8 · 80 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Page & Associates INC. American Family Insurance

★ 4.8 · 43 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Sodie Rivera - State Farm Insurance Agent

★ 4.8 · 17 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

CoreLogic Insurance Solutions

★ 4.8 · 4 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Camilla Jarman American Family Insurance

★ 4.6 · 102 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Unisource Insurance Associates, LLC

★ 4.6 · 36 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Bell Insurance Agency LLC

★ 4.6 · 9 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Augustine Agency LLC American Family Insurance

★ 4.5 · 47 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Eric Casey - State Farm Insurance Agent

★ 4.5 · 16 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Den-Wu SR22 Insurance Agency Wisconsin

★ 4.4 · 7 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

PL Baldwin Agency, LLC

★ 4.3 · 3 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Tosa Insurance Agency, LLC

★ 4.2 · 18 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Cities & Villages Mutual Insurance

★ 3.9 · 10 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Principal Financial Group

★ 3.8 · 4 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Markel

★ 3.5 · 8 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Aon

★ 3.0 · 4 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

My Choice Wisconsin

★ 2.6 · 64 reviews
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Independent General Agencies

★ 1.0 · 1 review
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Scott T Hochmuth Insurance Agency

No rating yet
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Prudential | Sue Tefft | Life Insurance & Financial Services

No rating yet
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

RTIS,LLC

No rating yet
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Prudential | Nate Mccardell | Life Insurance & Annuities

No rating yet
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Matthew Quade, Independent Insurance Broker

No rating yet
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

JTS Insurance

No rating yet
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

RJA Insurance Services Inc.

No rating yet
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Christopher Bering American Family Insurance

No rating yet
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Grand SR22 Insurance Wauwatosa

No rating yet
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

Steinbrenner

No rating yet
Insurance Agency · Wauwatosa

/ HelpCommon Questions

How do I choose a reliable insurance agency in Wauwatosa?+

Start with the rating — look for a insurance agency holding 4.5 stars or higher with a healthy number of recent reviews, which signals consistent, current service. Confirm they're properly licensed and insured for the work you need, and read a few reviews to see how they handle problems, not just praise. The listings below are sorted by Google rating to make this easier.

What's the typical cost of a insurance agency in Wauwatosa?+

Pricing varies widely by the scope of the job, materials, and how urgent the work is, so there's no single rate. The most reliable approach is to contact two or three insurance agencies directly for a quote on your specific situation. Use the "View on Google Maps" or "Visit Website" buttons on each listing to reach out.

Are these insurance agencies verified?+

Yes. Every listing is sourced from public Google Business Profile data — business name, rating, and review count — collected by our own crawl. We show only what's already public; we don't add or alter business details.

How can I contact a insurance agency?+

Click "View on Google Maps" to get directions, hours, and the business's public contact options, or "Visit Website" to reach them online. We don't publish private phone numbers or email addresses here — the business's own Google profile and website are the right place to get in touch.

I'm a business owner — how do I update or remove my listing?+

Email support@publicleads.com with the subject "Removal Request" and include your business name and city. We process removal and correction requests within 48 hours.